Sheff was a hired gun, kind of like Reggie. And he could MASH! And his off the field will be, 'boys will be boys,' thirty years from now. Of the rest you named, Nomar is a Red Sox Mattingly, so no go. The Killer B's, Biggio and Bagwell, certainly drove those Houston teams. I think Biggio will get in not Bagwell. The Hall voters have a hard time putting in a guy who was mostly a Dh and I think that will be Martinez's downfall. He lucks out when Frank Thomas comes up though. Frank played the field longer than Edgar, but, the Big Hurt did a lot of that damage from the DH spot. Raines and Rickey Henderson were almost the same guy, but Rick was better at being that guy, so I don't think 'Rock,' makes it in. Someone needs to come up with a Tinkers to Evers to Chance for Alan Trammell and Lou Whitaker. those guys were AWESOME in the field. Not sure that gives Trammell the cachet to get in. Piazza is the best hitting catcher of all time. He's got my vote. And Larry Walker was a professional hitter. Coors Field or not, that guy could see the ball hit the ball. Might could make a case for him. And last but not least, Schilling, who I am conflicted over. Super props on the heart and talent matching the moments, but, he did them as a Sox AND a D'back to my Yankees. And for that, I can't forgive him.