Great article. I've had a similar experience as Gus has had. I like the game but am not overly fawning at it.
Yes I ended up buying the game even after I returned it. I don't regret the purchase and the game is great and all but it won't hold my attention for long. That's just me though. Still the good thing about having this game in my library is I can come back to it later and play again due to it's high replayability factor.