Started by Telemecus, September 14, 2019, 01:29:32 PM
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: Telemecus on September 15, 2019, 06:30:45 AM.Even if you are not able to play now but have some interest in future let us know. Usually we have a reserve list of players. There is also the option to join as an interested observer or advisor. The only rule is that once you have the password and seen the plans of one side you cannot then join the other side.
Quote from: Tripoli on September 15, 2019, 09:56:21 AMPut me on the reserve list for now. Not usre I can commit, but I'd be interested in possibly playing in the future.
Quote from: Original Game Sign Up PostThe idea is that both novices and more experienced players can be team members. It is not meant to be a coaching game, although if players are happy to do that that is fine. Generally though each player should have their own area of responsibility and succeed or fail by their own efforts. However it is an opportunity to see how others play from the same side and play collaboratively a side of War in the East. Some things that are easy for a single player game to do are harder for a group, and that is part of the challenge.As a wargame it should be approached by all in the spirit of fun.Set UpPBEMCampaign 1941-45 [Edit: changed from Bitter End in original post]Latest public beta version and update at least when steam does[Edit: we will not update to v1.12 when it is published as official steam beta but remain with v1.11.03 steam official release instead]Game options, unless there is a consensus otherwise among those who join, will be-fog of war-random weather-+1 Soviet bonus [Edit: changed from no bonus]-mild blizzard [Edit: changed from full blizzard]-better cv maths [Edit added]House rules-no suicide mission para drops or naval invasions (e.g. sacrificed to displace airbases or rail repair), such missions should be realistic with a plan to keep them in supply and with relief forces to join them.-Axis Supreme Commander will not perform any combat missions (e.g. air missions) [Edit added since original post to reflect perceived experience imbalance, if there is no imbalance this needs to be revisited]If there is a consensus for other house rules these can be added, but it is best kept to a minimumTeam and Roles[Edit: Rules since changed to remove this section and to leave it to each side to decide their teams without rules]Each team should include- 1 Supreme Commander: decides the allocations to each of the other commanders (e.g. units, points, rail cap, manpower, leaders etc.) and their responsibilities (e.g. boundary maps, objectives). This can include protocols on how different players can use the same units during the same turn (e.g. air groups, SUs), strategy many turns ahead etc. The supreme commander could also undertake strategic aspects of warfare (air missions, industry etc.) but should not be another ground commander. Anything relevant to only the responsibilities of one commander should be left to that commander. As well as aiming to win the game, the Supreme commander is also responsible for ensuring all their team players have the substantial game they expect.- North, Centre/West, South and (optionally) other ground commanders: they cannot also be the Supreme Commander and are responsible for "pushing the units" for all ground forces in contact with the enemy as well as any other roles the team decides- Others (optionally): if the team agrees and other roles can be found. Suggestions have included air commanders, deputy ground commanders and even ministers of production and propaganda!Each team must have-1 Team Manager (who can also have one of the roles above and does not have to be the Supreme Commander): makes sure that the save file is with somebody to take their go, that there is no ambiguity whose go it is, and it is not left idle during their sides turn. When a player cannot take their go and there is no way to swap the sequence round for someone else to take their go, the team manager should arrange for someone to cover that players go for that turn. Their aim is for that team's turn to be finished as quickly as possible. They should also recruit replacments when a vacancy occurs. [My experience of the other team game is this is a substantial side job - even hardcore wargamers have real lives and getting multiple calendars coordinated is not easy. And getting a replacement for a vacancy entails more than posting once in the forums that there is a vacancy. Having someone responsible for this helps!]Teams that opt for further ground commanders or other roles should take care to not unduly increase the length of the game as a result.To start the game each team must have at least a different person as Supreme, North and South commander (Centre/West can be allocated between North and South).If the team does not at least have a different person as Supreme, North, Centre/West and South commander they must post they are looking to fill this vacancy in this thread and be open for another joining the team to fill these roles.When teams have no vacancies and extra roles are not possible for those expressing an interest here they will be added to the reserves list and invited to join when the next vacancy occurs.A player vacates their place in the game when they post so in this thread, or if they have been incomunicado since their last turn and are not available to take their turn when it comes again.Anyone who has played on one side cannot later play on the other side (they will know the other team's password and plans).Sequence of PlayPlay consists of each commander taking their go and uploading their save files at the end of their go to dropbox for the next commander in this sequence1. Supreme Commander receives end of turn file from opposing team and takes their go at the start2. Other team commanders take their go in an agreed sequence, if necessary altered by the team manager to make sure there are no idle periods3. After all other commanders on a team have finished the Supreme Commander takes a further go at the end4. The end turn button is pressed for the end of turn save and the result is uploaded to dropbox for the other side to take their turnAll players should be members of and upload their end of go saves to a single game dropbox and use a common file name schema (e.g. "2by3+ 010-Axis.02 North Finished" where 2by3+ is the name of the game, 10-Axis would be the turn number-side, 2 the go for that side during the turn and the last part their description of the go). Players of the other team will be able to see the progress but not open the files without the password.Time: Commitment and PaceExperience from the other team game is that when teams are doing OK each side takes a week to do a turn. The fastest has been two days, the longest many weeks. Turns get quicker when there are no team changes, and are likely to be quicker during less intense mud turns say. However even with quick players the multiple handovers do make the game slower. Players will have to accept this, but should endeavour to not unnecessarily lengthen the game and take responsibility not to leave it idle while others wait.Realitically this means at the start you are only likely to have the save file to take your go for an evening or two every two weeks. You can spend as much or as little time as you like outside of this to think about and plan your go, write AARs, strategise with team members, trashtalk the other side or engage in any other type of role play. But if your only interest is "pushing the units" and you are frustrated by this pace you should not consider this as your main or only game. On the other hand if you are not able to commit to a full on solo game against someone else this could be ideal.Also this pace, even if it accelerates, means the end of the game will be a long way off. This means it is more suited to someone interested in the tactical play turn by turn, the team colloboration, or even the results by the end of each campaigning season. It may not suit someone whose main interest is in seeing a win or lose screen at the end of 200+ turns. On the other hand it does mean you are not individually obliged to stay with the game until the end. You can just play to the end of a campaigning season or even just a couple of turns to cover between one player leaving and another joining. All that is asked is that you are upfront about your commitment to your team mates and give as much notice of leaving as possible to allow a replacement to be found.CommunicationsThere will be a forum thread for both teams for trashtalk and, hopefully, posting an AAR alternately by each team with a suitable delay. Each team may also have their own forum thread to post commands and operate the team or for any role play they like, and/or instead post a seperate AAR; and to which they can instruct members of the other team not to visit. Each team may also want to have its own dropbox just for that team side to hold files in common other than those posted to its AAR - if so all team members should be given access.Future changesOnce the game has started rules can be amended or added to when there is no objection by any of the current players of the game. Rule changes must be posted in this thread so that future joiners of the game can know them.How to join or express interestPost your intention to join here - you can express a preference for a side or role. If you suggest a role other than the four defined above (Supreme, North, Centre/West, South), or even have no role, you may want to describe how it would work and why it would be good - but may have to accept the team may not be able to accommodate it.If you are unsure or still considering it do feel free to post so here or PM me.Feel free also to ask any questions.
Quote from: ArizonaTank on September 18, 2019, 04:23:52 PMWhat pace do you play at? A turn every few days?