GrogHeads Forum

History, Reference, Research, and GrogTalk => Military (and other) History => Topic started by: JasonPratt on December 11, 2015, 02:42:00 PM

Title: MI6 hired C. S. Lewis to do what...?
Post by: JasonPratt on December 11, 2015, 02:42:00 PM
A fellow Lewis scholar (whose family goes to a church I attend though I've rarely met him myself), Harry Poe, claims he recently bought a 78 rpm record from a sale on Ebay, featuring a lecture read by C. S. Lewis as part of a propaganda campaign.

But it isn't what you may be thinking of, namely his radio "Broadcast Talks" on Christian apologetics, eventually collected with some other material into Mere Christianity. Though to be fair that was a type of propaganda in its own way, too.

No, this was for Iceland, and had nothing specifically to do with religion. Rather it was intended to help Icelanders feel solidarity with the English, while British troops were fortifying Iceland against Nazi invasion.

By pre-emptively invading Iceland themselves.

http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2015/december-web-only/cs-lewis-secret-agent.html

QuoteOn that same morning in May, however, [that the Nazis started the Netherland / Belgium / France campaign,] the British did the next best thing they could do to help Denmark [already conquered in a day] and the rest of Europe: They launched a surprise invasion of Iceland, which was part of the Kingdom of Denmark. Iceland's strategic significance in the North Atlantic had been known since the Viking voyages a thousand years earlier. Iceland sits along the arc of islands that include Britain, Ireland, Iceland, Greenland, and Newfoundland. Each island became a staging ground for pushing farther westward. In the Battle of the Atlantic, Iceland could have provided Germany with a strategic naval and air base. Instead, thanks to the British invasion, Iceland provided the ideal base for seaplanes to search for the German naval vessels that prowled the Atlantic sinking the merchant fleet with its crucial supplies.

Though British control of Iceland was critical, Britain could not afford to deploy its troops to hold the island when greater battles loomed elsewhere, beginning with the struggle for North Africa. Holding Iceland depended upon the goodwill of the people of Iceland who never had asked to be invaded by the British. If Britain retained Icelandic goodwill, then Churchill could occupy the island with reserve troops rather than his best fighting forces.

This was the strategic situation in which C. S. Lewis was recruited. And his mission was simple: To help win the hearts of the Icelandic people.

Mainly by drawing cultural parallels, mainly by examples of literary admiration of English authors for Norse languages and culture. (Lewis' day job was a professor of medieval English language and history, being tapped years later into writing the Oxford History of English Literature on 16th century English literature excluding drama, an early edition of which I'm proud to own and have read.)

How Dr. Poe knows this isn't a hoax recording, I'm not sure. He admits MI6 records are still sealed, and that aside from a curious slip in a letter to a friend about doing a test voice recording for someone (not for the Broadcast Talks which were later in August and which being done live wouldn't need a test recording) Lewis never talked about such a mission (which naturally he wouldn't have). Lewisiana has had a habit of suspicious hoaxes since his death (at least one of which I'm afraid Dr. P has helped inadvertently perpetrate while claiming to have verified the material, though that's another very long debate).

Recordings of his distinctive voice (borrowed by Tolkien for Treebeard in the Lord of the Rings) are ultra-rare, with only a fragment from a reading of The Four Loves surviving (so far as I know).

No doubt there'll be a book in it eventually, or maybe a special -- Dr. Poe has already booked the first public performance of the record at Oxford next summer. Parts 1 and 3 of the lecture are extant; parts 2 and 4 (which would be on another record) are missing. I can already see a potential problem: I know how multi-part records were printed for sequential play in a record stack, and this isn't the order. Record 1 (which starts on the bottom of the stack) should have part 1 on the front and part 4 on the back; Record 2 (which starts on the top of the stack) should have part 2 on the front and part 3 on the back. Thus the parts drop in order, and when the broadcaster flips the platters as a stack the parts will drop in order again.

Maybe this oddity can be explained by the turntable hardware of the time being different somehow?  ??? Perhaps two turntables were expected to be played in sequence, with flips for record 1 when side 2 started playing and for record 2 when side 3 started playing?

Anyway, it's a curious look at the strategic situation of the North Atlantic in WW2.  :)
Title: Re: MI6 hired C. S. Lewis to do what...?
Post by: Martok on December 12, 2015, 07:00:02 AM
Fascinating -- if true.