JudgeDredd might want to look away at this point... ;)
http://www.celticfringe.net/history/brave.htm
lol
I am WELL aware of how fictional the film was. That's Hollywood.
Still a good movie
;D I was pretty sure you did. I was just teasing you... ^-^
I agree it's a fun alternative history movie, but like the guy from Clann Tartan says, had they kept to a truthful historical version they would have had a damn good story too. The article is actually quite interesting, coming from a guy who researched Robert the Bruce.
The trouble with Hollywood is they frequently misrepresent history, and people who don't know any better believe it...see the U571 film (capture of the enigma machine) for example (actually the incident relates to the capture of U110 by HMS Bulldog. U571 was sunk by an Australian flying boat and was never boarded).
Yeah - there was absolutely no need for it to be changed in the way it was...the story has "appeal" without having to be a documentary or a docu-soap.
The author of "Run Silent, Run Deep" was furious with the changes that Hollywood made to his story. Ned Beach was a very successful submariner and based the book very closely on his experiences.
His second book, "Dust on the Sea" was in some respects better, and very closely based on an american wolfpack attack on a Japanese convoy in 1944. Since the movie had been quite successful, his agent thought they'd make a bundle by selling the movie rights to the follow up. Beach wouldn't have any of it.
Once burned, he never considered letting Hollywood hacks ruin his plots.
His widow, Ingrid, who still lives in Washington, DC, however still gets residuals from the movie and cheers when Clark Gable dies.
He dies? :o
^Spoiler Alert!
Quote from: JudgeDredd on September 20, 2016, 05:22:27 PM
Yeah - there was absolutely no need for it to be changed in the way it was...the story has "appeal" without having to be a documentary or a docu-soap.
Exactly.
Quote from: besilarius on September 20, 2016, 06:49:18 PM
The author of "Run Silent, Run Deep" was furious with the changes that Hollywood made to his story. Ned Beach was a very successful submariner and based the book very closely on his experiences.
His second book, "Dust on the Sea" was in some respects better, and very closely based on an american wolfpack attack on a Japanese convoy in 1944. Since the movie had been quite successful, his agent thought they'd make a bundle by selling the movie rights to the follow up. Beach wouldn't have any of it.
Once burned, he never considered letting Hollywood hacks ruin his plots.
His widow, Ingrid, who still lives in Washington, DC, however still gets residuals from the movie and cheers when Clark Gable dies.
I get that. There was a series on TV recently called "What really happened" and watching the Pearl Harbor episode the historian was keen to point out that people actually believe the Hollywood versions as "history" and wanted to set the record straight with a factual account of what happened, which frankly was more interesting than the fictional version - as it often is.
I've often thought the most accurate depiction in 'Braveheart' was Patrick Mc Goohan's Edward I. One of the real Bastards of English history and a near perfect movie villain. The rest was just entertainment.