GrogHeads Forum

1960 was rough on everyone.  Maybe you weren't familiar with the songs.  Or maybe that style of music just doesn't appeal to you.  Or maybe, you're old enough to have heard those songs a millions times and can't bear to listen to them ONE...MORE...TIME!!!  But I have a suspicion that all the polls past say...1964 or so, will interest you a great deal more.  Starting with 1970. 

I wish I had the intestinal fortitude to do a proper 64 song bracket for each year.  I had to cull the list from 47 to 16 and I thought THAT was being stingy.  The getting to 47 that is.  There are some great, great songs that won't be included in this poll, but, I hope you like the ones I did choose. 

The 1/16





The 8/9





The 5/12





The 4/13





The 6/11





The 3/14





The 7/10





The 2/15

Tough choices.. well done.  \m/

Ah, the 70s. Now I can start voting.  O0

Glad you could make it, fellas!  :)

War Pigs a 15 seed?!?!

And if War Pigs is on the list, why wouldn't Paranoid be instead!?!?

(War Pigs is a better song, but Paranoid actually charted and would be considered the 'bigger hit')

Good stuff, Dawg. Some of those really bring back memories. Oh Gawd....the James Gang!!!! This was, for me, the best sweet 16 bracket so far, which is cool   8)

And did you piss in Brant's Cheerios....again?

I figured if I was going to catch consistent shit from anyone, it would be Brant.  It's all good though.  Love to see the passion behind people's musical tastes.

And in answer to your War Pigs question, I'll answer your with another question, why Into the Mystic instead of Moondance?  Honestly, I am bored to tears of Paranoid.  But, there will be other songs I could never hear again and it would be too soon.  And some of those will appear in future brackets.  Besides, I had four Sabbath songs to choose from, the two previously mentioned, Iron Man and The Wizard.  I wanted to take the Wizard, but, I'm still not sure what audience I am playing to, so, I am trying to err on the side of what most people will know.  As I mentioned in the OP, I cut 31 songs from 1970 to get to 16 and there were probably half again as many that could have easily made this a 64 song bracket.  I just don't have the fortitude to do 64 songs for 40 years.  It's already going to be 640 as it is.

Good selection, and tough choices!  One or two of my top-ten-all-time-best songs are on this list (although to be honest I probably have 200 top-ten-all-time-best songs).

I also looked up the songs that came out in 1970 and the ones that charted that year.  You had a lot to choose from, which must've made your job tough.

Quote from: MetalDog on April 16, 2017, 09:35:03 PM
But, there will be other songs I could never hear again and it would be too soon.

As we get in to the 1970s, there are going to be a few songs that fall into this category for me.  They may be great songs, but back in the days of radio and LPs, I just heard them way too many times.

Quote from: trailrunner on April 16, 2017, 09:53:27 PM
Good selection, and tough choices!  One or two of my top-ten-all-time-best songs are on this list (although to be honest I probably have 200 top-ten-all-time-best songs).

I also looked up the songs that came out in 1970 and the ones that charted that year.  You had a lot to choose from, which must've made your job tough.

I am keeping a list of all the ones I didn't use.  I may or may not do something with them at a different time.  But there's a LOT of them ;)

Quote from: MetalDog on April 16, 2017, 09:35:03 PM
I figured if I was going to catch consistent shit from anyone, it would be Brant.  It's all good though.  Love to see the passion behind people's musical tastes.

It's a given, Brant's going to have something to bRANT about in these playoffs.  \m/

Guys - seriously...  you're talking about a dude that's been a giant music fan going back to the early 80s, has a CD/cassette/LP collection in the low thousands, and a few years working on the fringes of the music business as a radio DJ, musician, producer, and promoter :)

You're darn right I'm going to have some comment on darn near every one of these! :D

Excellent choices brother man! Into the Mystic to the Final Four at least! War Pigs over Paranoid every time.  O0

Quote from: bubblehead1971 on April 17, 2017, 11:46:07 AMWar Pigs over Paranoid every time.

note what I said above O:-)

Quote from: bayonetbrant on April 16, 2017, 08:56:34 PM(War Pigs is a better song, but Paranoid actually charted and would be considered the 'bigger hit')

Quote from: bubblehead1971 on April 17, 2017, 11:46:07 AM
Excellent choices brother man! Into the Mystic to the Final Four at least! War Pigs over Paranoid every time.  O0

Glad you like the choices, bub.  And don't mind Brant.  He loves music like we do.  Just some really...off the beaten path stuff sometimes.  He turned me on to The Revivalists, among others, so I will always be grateful :)

As a point of information to all our voters, while you can vote for up to half the bracket, you should be voting for each matchup, not just what song you like.  For example, there are 9 members who have voted in this poll and the 2/15 matchup has 11 votes.  Now, I'm no math major, but, if you're following directions, there should never be more votes for a matchup than people who voted.  So if you could please endeavor to keep the votes within the matchups, I sure would appreciate it.  Thanks for taking the time to vote.  I really like doing these and it helps to have folks right along with me.   O0

Surely Brant can dig out who the blockheads are and publicly shame them?  ::)

If Brant could do that, I'm afraid of who he might find ;)

Quote from: MetalDog on April 17, 2017, 06:18:51 PM
He turned me on to The Revivalists, among others, so I will always be grateful :)

Mrs Bayonet and I are kicking around the idea of New Year's Eve in N'awlins at the annual Revivalists show there.  Y'all feel free to join us.

We're planning to be down there anyway for Christmas with family and bonfires on Christmas Eve in Lutcher.

Quote from: MetalDog on April 17, 2017, 06:23:34 PM
As a point of information to all our voters, while you can vote for up to half the bracket, you should be voting for each matchup, not just what song you like.  For example, there are 9 members who have voted in this poll and the 2/15 matchup has 11 votes.  Now, I'm no math major, but, if you're following directions, there should never be more votes for a matchup than people who voted.  So if you could please endeavor to keep the votes within the matchups, I sure would appreciate it.  Thanks for taking the time to vote.  I really like doing these and it helps to have folks right along with me.   O0

yeah, I've just been voting for the ones I like and ignoring the matchups.  I'll pay more attention from now on.

^Thank you, sir.  Much appreciated.

Quote from: bayonetbrant on April 17, 2017, 07:21:11 PM

Quote from: MetalDog on April 17, 2017, 06:18:51 PM
He turned me on to The Revivalists, among others, so I will always be grateful :)

Mrs Bayonet and I are kicking around the idea of New Year's Eve in N'awlins at the annual Revivalists show there.  Y'all feel free to join us.

We're planning to be down there anyway for Christmas with family and bonfires on Christmas Eve in Lutcher.

Whatever mad money I have will be spent on Origins.  Would LOVE to see them in their natural habitat :)

Quote from: MetalDog on April 17, 2017, 06:23:34 PM
As a point of information to all our voters, while you can vote for up to half the bracket, you should be voting for each matchup, not just what song you like.  For example, there are 9 members who have voted in this poll and the 2/15 matchup has 11 votes.  Now, I'm no math major, but, if you're following directions, there should never be more votes for a matchup than people who voted.  So if you could please endeavor to keep the votes within the matchups, I sure would appreciate it.  Thanks for taking the time to vote.  I really like doing these and it helps to have folks right along with me.   O0

I was wondering if this is what we were supposed to do, so thanks for the clarification.

Quite welcome.  And thank you for participating!