What is more valuable aggression or discipline?

Started by Mr. Bigglesworth, November 06, 2014, 01:30:32 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Mr. Bigglesworth

I have been reading Thucydides where he talks about the massing of the hoplites relying on the discipline of the soldiers to keep the line from breaking.

Of course I have to wonder, in a modern military with ranged weapons, does the pendulum swing back towards the fighting skill of the individual? I am not considering mechanized or combined arms battle, just small engagements of elite infantry.

Assuming equal levels of technical skills, what wins? A group of natural fighters that are aggressive or a disciplined group that use mutual support?
"Once more unto the breach, dear friends, once more; "
- Shakespeare's Henry V, Act III, 1598

bayonetbrant

Quote from: Mr. Bigglesworth on November 06, 2014, 01:30:32 AMA group of natural fighters that are aggressive or a disciplined group that use mutual support?

The relative success of tactical engagement involving US / NATO / coalition soldiers vs Taliban / AQI / etc "fighters" who have the reputation of being fierce and aggressive might help answer that.  Western forces tend to be trained, and disciplined enough to stay within that training, and success follows on the battlefield.
The key to surviving this site is to not say something which ends up as someone's tag line - Steelgrave

"their citizens (all of them counted as such) glorified their mythology of 'rights'...and lost track of their duties. No nation, so constituted, can endure." Robert Heinlein, Starship Troopers

Centurion40

Any time is a good time for pie.

Smuckatelli

Quote from: Mr. Bigglesworth on November 06, 2014, 01:30:32 AM
Assuming equal levels of technical skills, what wins? A group of natural fighters that are aggressive or a disciplined group that use mutual support?

My opinion; natural aggressive fighters will win the battle and medals. The disciplined group will win the war.

Martok

"Like we need an excuse to drink to anything..." - Banzai_Cat
"I like to think of it not as an excuse but more like Pavlovian Response." - Sir Slash

"At our ages, they all look like jailbait." - mirth

"If we had lines here that would have crossed all of them. For the 1,077,986th time." - Gusington

"Government is so expensive that it should at least be entertaining." - airboy

"As long as there's bacon, everything will be all right." - Toonces

Mr. Bigglesworth

I will second that as very insightful, especially coming from an old warrior whose expertise in such things gets much respect.

One caveat - I think supply is more important than troops for winning the war. Shocking? I can think of 2 examples of inferior naval powers that won the war using navies, with which they were newbs compared to their opponents. Rome vs Carthage. Sparta vs Athens. My thesis is the land power used the supply ability of navy, to win. In supply the lowest cost is pipeline, ship, railway, trucking, air. If you can force the opponent to have high supply costs, then disrupt that supply ability, their fighters are reduced to starving, immobile, rock throwers.
"Once more unto the breach, dear friends, once more; "
- Shakespeare's Henry V, Act III, 1598

Airborne Rifles

Discipline wins out, but it's not an either/or choice. The best trained and most discipline soldiers will also be aggressive, in a disciplined way. I always tell my soldiers that well-disciplined team with inferior weapons will beat a sloppy team with superior weapons any day.

And Mr. B, in the army we have a saying: "amateurs talk about tactics. Professionals talk about logistics." When I look at many of the great captains of history and i see this is true (Marlborough and Grant come to mind).

GDS_Starfury

Quote from: Airborne Rifles on November 06, 2014, 09:58:32 PM
Discipline wins out, but it's not an either/or choice. The best trained and most discipline soldiers will also be aggressive, in a disciplined way. I always tell my soldiers that well-disciplined team with inferior weapons will beat a sloppy team with superior weapons any day.

the IDF pretty much proves this point pre 1973.
Jarhead - Yeah. You're probably right.

Gus - I use sweatpants with flannel shorts to soak up my crotch sweat.

Banzai Cat - There is no "partial credit" in grammar. Like anal sex. It's either in, or it's not.

Mirth - We learned long ago that they key isn't to outrun Star, it's to outrun Gus.

Martok - I don't know if it's possible to have an "anti-boner"...but I now have one.

Gus - Celery is vile and has no reason to exist. Like underwear on Star.